CDXList

Costello's Rare Coins

Halesite, New York

Address
187 Park Avenue, Halesite, NY, 11743
VerifiedU.S. CoinsBullion

Costello's Rare Coins in Halesite, New York is a U.S. Coins, Bullion dealer listed on CDXList.com. Contact the shop for current inventory, buy/sell pricing, and hours.

Dealer location

Shop address — not a coin show venue.

187 Park Avenue, Halesite, NY, 11743Open in Google Maps

Collector notes

Visiting a coin shop

A few notes before you walk into Costello's Rare Coins in Halesite, NY. These rotate daily. They are general collector etiquette from CDXList — not this shop’s house rules. When something is unclear, ask the person at the counter.

  1. Say thank you even if you do not deal

    Looking is part of the hobby. Buying or selling is not required. If they spent time with you, say thanks and mean it. A short good visit is how regulars are made. A review later, if you had a fair experience, helps the shop more than a vague promise to “come back sometime.”

  2. What happens at the counter is private

    Do not repeat another customer’s name, address, or what they sold. Do not film the register. Shops are small towns. Discretion is part of being a decent visitor. It is also how you get treated like one.

  3. Show week can empty the shop — or pack it

    If the dealer is on the road, the store may be closed or on shorter hours. If they just got back, they may be unpacking. Check this listing for upcoming shows and call if your visit is important. It is not personal. The bourse is part of the business.

  4. Do not crack a graded holder in the shop

    PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and CAC holders are part of the product. Opening one at the counter to “see it better” can wreck the value. If you want it out, that is a decision you make at home, not a demonstration.

  5. What is in the case today may be gone tomorrow

    Coin shops turn inventory. A picture from last month is not a hold. If you want a date or a grade, call or start a want list. Showing up and hoping the exact piece is still there is how people get disappointed.