Bayshore Bullion Exchange
Keansburg, New Jersey
- Address
- 75 Route 36, Keansburg, NJ, 07734
- Phone
- (732) 895-5200
- Website
- bayshorebullionexchange.com/
- Private form — use Email shop
CONTACT INFORMATION CALL OR TEXT 732-895-5200 EMAIL andrew@bayshorebullionexchange.com WEBSITE bayshorebullionexchange.com LOCATION Keansburg, NJ By Appointment Only OVER 15 YEARS SERVING NEW JERSEY'S PRECIOUS METALS COMMUNITY SEND US A MESSAGE WHAT WE DO GOLD & SILVER BULLION Gold bars, silver bars, and investment products. SCRAP GOLD BUYING Top payouts for scrap gold, jewelry, and more. DEALER
Upcoming coin shows
Shows this dealer plans to attend. Tags are what they plan to bring — not a promise of stock.
- Detroit Area Coin Shows – Southfield Attending Booth t-23Nov 8, 2026 · Southfield, MINote: Pre-33 Gold Graded Coins
Dealer location
Shop address — not a coin show venue.
Collector notes
Visiting a coin shop
A few notes before you walk into Bayshore Bullion Exchange in Keansburg, NJ. These rotate daily. They are general collector etiquette from CDXList — not this shop’s house rules. When something is unclear, ask the person at the counter.
Know roughly what you brought
You do not need to be an expert. A simple list — silver dollars, a few proofs, a bag of wheat cents — helps. “I have no idea, you tell me” on a mixed box is fine once. It is harder when the box is huge and you cannot say what you want out of the visit.
A hold is a promise. Mean it.
If they hold a coin for you, ask how long and how you pay. Come back or call. Do not park the same piece at two shops. Dealers remember the customer who used a hold as a free option. They also remember the one who did what they said.
Insurance and probate need different paperwork
If a lawyer, an executor, or an insurer sent you, say so. Bring what papers you have. The shop may not be the appraiser you need, and they will tell you. That honesty is useful. It is better than leaving with the wrong kind of number.
Do not crack a graded holder in the shop
PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and CAC holders are part of the product. Opening one at the counter to “see it better” can wreck the value. If you want it out, that is a decision you make at home, not a demonstration.
Stay with your coins
Do not leave a box on the counter and wander the cases. Do not ask the dealer to watch your bag while you go to the car. Your lot stays in front of you until the deal is done or you pack up. That is how both sides stay comfortable.